So when we were saving for our big vacation we had (well and still do) a $100 a week budget for grocery shopping. I was working REALLY hard to stay within budget. I'm not sure if others are going to think this is a lot or not. This is for 5 people (plus my mother in law during the week) and we don't really eat out. Then Jeramie's two boys every other weekend. And I do believe that 13 year old and 9 year old boys eat more than my husband does!! I do not look forward to feeding Jackson and
Wyland at that age. This grocery shopping does not include what I spend at Costco each week either, that's a separate budgeted amount. I've always been a devoted Target shopper for my groceries. We have a routine every Sunday, I meet my mum and sometimes my brother Mike at Costco, we grab lunch and then shop there and head straight over to Target to do the remaining. The kids like to come and it always seems to turn into an all day event. Since my kids don't leave the house for daycare or anything and I'm not home during the day I feel bad that they don't get out all that much so this is how they end up in my shopping cart. I will also mention that this isn't recommended. Sometimes I feel like I can't even think when I'm juggling the kids as well. But if I take all the kids shopping on Sunday then Jeramie cleans the house so it's a good trade. Anyway, I don't even remember why but for several weekends in a row my mum was out of town and so I was on my own for grocery shopping. So I got a little crazy and tried some new stores. Now I've already told some folks about this experience and some do not agree with my findings. I don't think I buy things that are out of the ordinary.
Of all the places I shopped I still prefer
Target for the shopping experience itself. However, I ALWAYS go over budget no matter how hard I try. I know it's because of all the other things they have available there. This includes the toy section that I usually let my kids choose a "prize" if they are good. The fact that I know the store so well is a big bonus. But aside from that I don't think of them as "expensive". I think they're average. They don't have the killer deals that other places have, but I'm also not willing to drive to 5 different stores each week to pick up just the deal items only. I always end up with other stuff that more than counters for the money I saved.
Smith's was probably my worst experience of all. I couldn't find
ANYthing. Now I know that part of it is that I'm not used to shopping there but I wasn't used to shopping at any of the other places either and things were still logically organized. Smith's on the other hand just didn't have things where you would expect them. I came in BARELY under budget but definitely paid way more for some things. I think they have a good bakery department though. Lots of yummy looking treats, but I can't speak for how they taste. Their produce section on the other hand seemed really small.
Harmon's is just too expensive. They have a great variety of stuff and the store is really nice. But everything is expensive. They do have the best
cheeseball in the valley though and I will go there specifically just for that. I like that they offer me stamps at the checkout too.
Albertson's / A Fresh Market is expensive too. I would go there over Smith's but I think they're more expensive. But at least I can find things when I'm there.
Walmart was pretty decent. If it wasn't for another store blowing them all out the water
Walmart probably would have been the winner. They are a great alternative.
I had planned to try
Macy's but never made it over there. Maybe one day.
The winner when it came down to it was
WinCo!! It's close to my house and literally on my way home from work, which if I'm shopping without Mum this is very convenient for me. You just can't beat the prices. Let me give you an example, Hot Dogs 96 cents! Big boxes (we're talking the big family size) of cereal $1.98! And I'm not talking the no-name kind, I got
Kelloggs Fruit Loops, Frosted Flakes and Apple Jacks.
Reiser Macaroni Salad $2.38 (normally in A Fresh Market this costs $6.99). Plus they have a pretty large selection of brands. There are still some things that I can't get there that I still end up at Target for. But overall their prices are absolutely ridiculously low for the exact same brands you would buy at Target or anywhere else. I can't speak for their meat or produce because I buy all that stuff at Costco anyway. Those prices I quoted they were from this week.
Now while I probably will never religiously shop there every single week because I still enjoy our Sunday routine. If I ever deviate from the routine I guarantee I'll be at
WinCo. Their prices are outstanding and the quality of the stuff is great. I've never gone over budget there. Some other key factors that assist in me controlling my grocery bill is don't take the kids for two reasons. First they always want me to buy them a toy and it's so hard to say no. Secondly they distract me from the job at hand and I start making bad decisions and then just rushing to get out of there while not thinking about what I'm doing. When I shop with a list (because as you know I'm a
menu planner) I only get what I need and don't end up throwing lots of stuff away, oh and I don't forget things either. If I'm alone I do well too, I don't dilly dally looking at stuff I don't need and then end up picking something up. I'm usually very focused and try to be quick while I do it to avoid distractions of those evil things I don't need. But it isn't nearly as fun either. I think perhaps part of the happy medium is I need to convince my Mum to go to
WinCo on Sunday's too, then it's the best of both worlds!! Oh and if I shop on another night on my way home from work then I don't feel guilty for not taking the kids.